Ace8 is the modernization practice of AceMQ.24/7 support from AceMQ after go-live
Book an Assessment
GuideBuyer's guide

How to choose a code review company: 9 questions to ask first.

The questions cover independence, access, the report and what happens after it. Score every firm on the same nine, including us.

AceMQ engineering team4 min readEngineer-reviewedUpdated

Stacks we work in

  • Java
  • Spring Boot
  • Kubernetes
  • PostgreSQL
  • Kafka
  • Docker
  • Terraform
  • GitHub Actions
  • Java
  • Spring Boot
  • Kubernetes
  • PostgreSQL
  • Kafka
  • Docker
  • Terraform
  • GitHub Actions
The short answer

Choose a code review company by asking nine questions: who reads the code, whether the firm gains from the findings, what access it needs, what the report looks like, how the price is set, and what it does after the report. Score each answer as specific, vague or missing. A firm that cannot show a sample report or name its reviewer is not ready for your code.

Next stepFixed-price assessmentInventory, risk score and a phased roadmap with a fixed price for phase one.Book a fixed-price assessment

01 · Approach

What should you look for in a code review company?

Look for independence, a clear access list, a report you can act on and a price tied to scope.

  1. 01

    A code audit is only as useful as the questions it answers, so decide the decision first: a rewrite, a deal, a handover or a launch.

  2. 02

    Use the nine questions below on every firm. For price context, see code audit cost. If you also plan to ask for fixes, decide now whether you want the same firm to do them, because that changes how you read questions 1 and 9.

02 · The nine questions

Which nine questions should you ask?

Ask all nine in writing, and score each answer 0 (missing), 1 (vague) or 2 (specific and checkable).

#QuestionA good answer sounds like
1Who does the audit gain from selling to me after it?A plain answer that names what else the firm sells, and a report that lists options, not only its own
2Who reads the code, and how experienced are they?A named senior engineer, not a tool's output alone
3What access do you need?Read access to a clone, an NDA first, no production credentials
4What does the report contain?A sample you can read, with severity ratings and evidence from the code
5Is there a fix-first list?Findings ordered by risk and effort, with a rough size per fix
6What is checked by tools and what by a person?Both are named, and a person reviews what the tools flag
7How is the price set?Fixed after scoping, with the scope written next to the number
8What happens to our code and the report afterward?Code deleted or returned on request; the report is yours
9What do you do after the report, and is it optional?Fix help is offered, priced separately and never required

03 · Independence

Does it matter if the auditor also sells the fix?

It matters, and it is not disqualifying.

  1. 01

    A firm that audits and fixes has a reason to find work, and a firm that only audits has a reason to find fault. Ask question 1 and read how the report presents options. A good report lets you take the fix list to any team.

04 · Access

What access should a code review company need?

A code review company should need read access to the source, build documentation and a few hours with an engineer who knows the system.

  1. 01

    It should not need production credentials or live customer data for a code audit. Firms publish different access terms: for example, CodeIT describes an NDA first and then repository access, and Cleveroad describes a similar request, NDA and scoping sequence (both checked 17 Nov 2026).

05 · Report

What should the report look like?

The report should open with a summary a non-engineer can read, then findings by area with evidence, then a ranked fix list.

  1. 01

    Published formats vary from a short PDF to a longer presentation-ready document. Ask for a sample, and check that each finding names a file or a behavior and not just a category. A useful finding says what was found, where, how serious it is and roughly what it costs to fix. A finding that only says the code has technical debt gives you nothing to decide on.

06 · Warning signs

What are the red flags?

how-to-choose-a-code-audit-company-review.mdEngineer review
Findings
F-01A fixed price quoted before anyone has seen the repository.
F-02No sample report, or a sample made only of tool screenshots.
F-03A request for production credentials or customer data.
F-04No named reviewer.
F-05A report that only recommends the firm's own rebuild.
F-06No answer on what happens to your code after the engagement.
Illustrative sample, not a real client report

07 · Disclosure

How would Ace8 answer?

Ace8 is the modernization practice of AceMQ, and it also sells modernization, so question 1 applies to us.

  1. 01

    The report lists options and is yours either way. We need read access to the code and nothing in production, sign an NDA first, and agree a fixed price after a scoping call. Fix help is optional. If you want to compare firms first, read code audit services compared.

  2. 02

    To see how we would answer the rest, request a code audit quote. For 24/7 run support after a fix or migration, AceMQ provides it; see supported after migration.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Short answers to what buyers ask first. Something else on your mind? Ask an engineer.

Ask the same nine questions of every firm and score each answer as specific, vague or missing. Start with independence, access and the sample report.

Start here

Know the cost before anything moves.

A fixed-price assessment gives you the inventory, the risk score and a phased plan. Scope and cost are fixed before the migration starts.

Inventory
Every application, its stack and what it depends on.
Risk score
Where a change is likely to break, ranked.
Phased plan
What moves first, which tools lead, and the fixed price.

Get in touch

Talk to a modernization engineer.

Tell us what you run today. An engineer, not a sales script, replies within one business day.

305-204-2607info@ace8.io

66 W. Flagler St. 9th Floor
Miami, FL 33130

What are you moving off? *

Fixed price. Scope and cost before any migration starts.